The Best Cutting Board America’s Test Kitchen 2022

The Best Cutting Board America's Test Kitchen

We have put the best cutting boards to test to compile this review. To begin with, we interviewed a bunch of industry experts. Based on their recommendations, few products were shortlisted and put to use.

Believe it or not, the best among them made it to this review. Basically, we had to discard a lot of products to come up with these finalists. So, let’s cut the chase and begin with this tried and tested cutting board review.

Best Cutting Board America’s Test Kitchen 2022

1. Prep Series Cutting Boards By Epicurean, 3 Piece, Natural (021-3PACK01)

Prep Series Cutting Boards by Epicurean, 3 Piece, Natural

In our quest to find the last cutting board you will ever need to buy, we landed on yet another marvel. The Prep Series Cutting Boards by Epicurean is definitely a cut above the scope. Hence, we found it worth our recommendation.

So, is this cutting board the ultimate kitchen tool for food preparation? Let’s find out in a short while as we dig deeper into the product details.

Product Features

The product is made from naturally renewable or recycled materials. It’s knife friendly, so this cutting board will not dull your knife. So, you can park your worries about damaging your favorite knife. Also, you won’t have to worry about bacteria colonizing on the surface because it’s nonporous.

The product is heat resistant up to 360 degrees. This is another distinct feature that sets it apart from the competition. Also, the product has a very thin profile making it easy to haul. Since it’s made from high-quality wood, it’s also maintenance free for the most part.

In Use

We found the product nice to cut on. The unique surface stance makes it easy to smoothly slice through anything you are cutting. It’s pretty lightweight too, so it’s easy to carry or grab. Moreover, this kitchen equipment can be easily hanged or stored without any fuss.

We used it for nearly a year, and it has stayed flat all this time. It required minimal TLC, and it has shown only minor wear and tear. Other than a few subtle scratches, this product has no other visible signs of damage. On the whole, it held up well against all kinds of kitchen tests.


Both sides of the cutting board can be put to effective use. One side can be used as a work surface, while the other side can be used to cut and chop all items. Moreover, it’s very thin and lightweight. So, storing them will never cause you a headache.

The Prep Series Cutting Boards by Epicurean is dishwasher safe. So, they can be effortlessly sanitized in any dishwasher out there. Also, this cutting board is not formulated in any far fleet corner of China. It’s made in the USA, and it meets all the necessary forestry guidelines.


Right off the package, the product will release an unpleasant formaldehyde smell. If you are sensitive to smells, you may not be able to tolerate it. However, this is a temporary hassle. The smell dissolves quickly after the first wash.

Overall, this cutting board can prove to be one of your favorite go-to kitchen tools. It does have the ability to impress users with its usability, functionality, and ease of use.

2. Mountain Woods 15-By-12-Inch Butcher Block Cutting Board

Mountain Woods 15-by-12-Inch Butcher Block Cutting Board

If you are looking for an extra thick wood cutting board, you have landed in the right spot. Given its thickness and strong built, the Mountain Woods 15-by-12-Inch Butcher Block Cutting Board would fit the bill perfectly over here. It’s one of those deals, which is deemed too good to be true. Oh, really? Let’s find out through this review.

Product Features

This product is made from black wood and maple. It offers a spacious working area. Plus, the high-quality material makes it a durable piece of kitchen equipment. So, it can be put to daily use in the kitchen.

It’s reversible, which implies that one can use both sides of the cutting board. For easy gripping, it has finger grooves on the side. Better yet, it’s deemed safe to be used with foods.

In Use

It has a solid weight to it to keep the tool from rocking while at use. Yes, it does hold well, and the smooth finish makes the job easier. Make no mistake; it’s not super heavy, yet very durable. Also, the wood was softer than what we imagined.

The built-in side handles come really handy during haul. After six months of heavy usage, the board still looks pleasant, and its performance is up to the mark. We must admit that it’s perfectly accurate to the item description for the most part.


It’s a tough piece of wood. The product can easily stand up to a lot of slicing and dicing. So, it can be used on a regular basis. Yes, it’s nice, sturdy, and durable enough to withstand daily knife use.

Above all, it’s attractive even when it’s not in use. Yes, it looks pretty exquisite in person. Compared to the products in the same spectrum, this one is less susceptible to denting, scratching, and other damages.


The product is not meant to be dish washed because it can cause the wood to shrink. Also, one would require mineral oil to prevent the wood from drying out. So, expect to spend some time on maintenance. As such, the product arrives with the directions for care.

On the whole, the product doesn’t disappoint. In fact, it won’t be an understatement to claim that the Mountain Woods 15-by-12-Inch Butcher Block Cutting Board is one of those products that’s born to impress.

3. CounterArt Flexible Cutting Mat With Food Icons

Flexible Cutting Board Mats Set of 3, Clear with Food Icons, Made in the USA of BPA Free Food Grade Plastic, 11.5” x 15” by Chop Chop

The CounterArt Flexible Cutting Mat is a unique item in its league. The ultra-flexible plastic cutting map is perfect for all kinds of food preparation. Spare a few more minutes and read till the end to know about this versatile cutting mat. Let’s begin with the product features.

Product Features

The product is shipped in a pack of 4 — one for every food group. They all have different colors with little labels on the top. So, it leaves no room for cross-contamination of meat and other food items. Moreover, they are made from a high-quality plastic material, which can last for several years and beyond. Its flexibility is one of its strong points.

It will help you easily transport the chopped food items from the cutting mat to the cooking bowl or food processor. Everything goes into the bowl like a breeze without any spillage because you can easily bend the mat to fit into the mouth of the bowl.

In Use

From our testing, we can state that they are durable enough for sharp knives. Yes, they withstood the test of time with some of the sharpest knives we owned. Moreover, they are so lightweight that four of them combined weighed far less than a wood cutting board.

Cleaning was never a hassle with these plastic cutting mats. They were thrown right into the dishwasher for easy and effortless clean up. Despite being plastic, they don’t show signs of wear and tear easily.


They are more cost-effective and versatile than any other product in its class. Moreover, they arrive in bright colors, which are pleasing to the eyes. Plus, they are very easy to store in your kitchen cabinet.

The CounterArt Flexible Cutting Mat would prove to be more sanitary than all other cutting boards out there. Also, the mats are odor free and lightweight. Unlike other inferior plastic cutting boards, you don’t have to hold these down to keep them flat.


Some degree of learning curve would be required over here, especially if you are used to a wooden cutting board. Some people choose to place a wood cutting board below these plastic mats to cut short the learning curve. You can use it in a similar fashion until you get a good hang of the product.

Overall, the CounterArt Flexible Cutting Mat is worth getting. By far, they are cost-effective and a highly functional kitchen tool. In a nutshell, they are good quality stuff sold at an affordable price point.

Round-Up Of The Best Cutting Boards

To cut back your work, let us sum up the review for you.

The OXO Good Grips Utility Cutting Board features nonporous and non-skidding surface. It can be used from both sides, and it will last for years to come. Moreover, it resists scratches and other damages. Better yet, it’s affordable too. So, this cutting board can be considered for all these glittering reasons.

The Woodworker’s Classic American Hardwood Butcher Block Cutting Board can prove to be a wonderful alternative for solid plastic boards. This wooden board is perfect for small kitchen owners who are possessive about their favorite knives.

If you are one of those environmental fuzzy guys out there, you can’t afford to miss the Prep Series Cutting Boards by Epicurean. It’s beautifully crafted to be a perfect cutting board, which is friendly for all types of knives.

The Mountain Woods 15-by-12-Inch Butcher Block Cutting Board could be your kitchen friend on several fronts. Money wise, space wise, and on the usability front, it won’t disappoint. Furthermore, it’s durable enough to withstand heavy kitchen use.

The CounterArt Flexible Cutting Mat with Food Icons is the most cost-efficient and versatile from the bunch. You can forget about food contamination for life by owning this kitchen tool. The product’s flexibility is its selling point too. It makes it super easy to transfer foods from the plastic mat to the pan or bowl.

Class dismissed for now. Hopefully, you have been able to decide which cutting board is best for your needs. So, go ahead and get one for yourself. Oh yes, happy shopping!